Verilog problems / Combinational Design
What you must build
Find both the minimum and maximum of three unsigned bytes at once — the basic building block of any sorting network or range check.
Engineers use “Min/Max Finder” as a building block in combinational design. Interviewers ask for the same ports and the same corner cases this judge covers. Completing it in the browser is the same skill as writing synthesizable RTL at work, minus the EDA license.
a and b first, then compare the winner against c. The min follows the mirror-image tree using <= instead of >=. Swapping which tree feeds which output — computing the max tree but wiring it to min_val, and vice versa — compiles fine and even passes on inputs where all three values happen to be equal, but is backwards everywhere else.Port contract
The judge instantiates exactly these ports. Extra ports or a different module name fail to elaborate.
| Name | Dir | Width | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
| a | input | 8 | First value |
| b | input | 8 | Second value |
| c | input | 8 | Third value |
| min_val | output | 8 | Smallest of the three |
| max_val | output | 8 | Largest of the three |
How to approach this kata
This is an introductory kata. Prefer a clear continuous assignment or a small combinational always block. Name the module top_module and keep the port list identical to the table — the hidden testbench instantiates that name.
Hidden tests instantiate top_module, drive the ports, and compare every sample against a golden model. They do not grade coding style. They do grade X/Z, off-by-one counters, and ignoring enables. Sign in only when you want the run saved on the leaderboard — the specification below is public.
Starter shape
Copy this skeleton into the editor (or press Reset starter). Fill the body; do not rename the module.
module top_module( input [7:0] a, input [7:0] b, input [7:0] c, output [7:0] min_val, output [7:0] max_val ); // Your code here — a 2-comparison tree for max, and the mirror-image tree for min. endmodule
Why this shows up in interviews
Min/Max Finder sits under Combinational Design (combinational, comparator). Concept: A nested-comparison tree finds the max in two comparisons: compare a and b first, then compare the winner against c . The min follows the mirror-image tree using <= instead of >= . Swapping which tree feeds which output — computing the max tree but wiring it to min_val , and vice versa — compiles fine and even passes on inputs where all three values happen to be equal, but is backwards everywhere else.
A passing solution is synthesizable intent: no delays in the DUT, no initial blocks inside top_module, and no reference to testbench tasks. Use blocking assignments only in combinational always blocks; use non-blocking for registers clocked by clk.
Related problems
- 2-to-1 Multiplexer — Select between two 1-bit inputs using sel. When sel=0 output a; when sel=1 output b.
- 1-Bit Full Adder — Compute sum and carry-out for a + b + cin.
- 4-to-1 Multiplexer — Select one of four 1-bit inputs using a 2-bit sel. sel=00→in0, 01→in1, 10→in2, 11→in3.
- 4-to-2 Priority Encoder — Output the index of the highest-priority (MSB-most) set bit in a 4-bit input, plus a valid flag when any bit is set.
FAQ
What does this problem require?
What does the Min/Max Finder problem ask for? Find both the minimum and maximum of three unsigned bytes at once — the basic building block of any sorting network or range check. Implement it as Verilog module top_module with the listed ports.
Combinational or sequential?
Is Min/Max Finder combinational or sequential? Tags: combinational, comparator. Follow the clock/reset ports if they appear in the table; if there is no clock, use continuous assignment or combinational always @(*).
How does the auto-grader work?
How is Min/Max Finder graded? A hidden SystemVerilog/Verilog testbench in the EcrioniX judge simulates your module in the browser. You pass when every directed vector matches, including the waveform contract shown on this page.